From historic inns to boutique coastal retreats, these properties offer a variety of lodging options across Long Island's South Fork and Shelter Island.
Key facts
- •Faraway in Sag Harbor features 67 guest rooms and a design history linked to figures like Truman Capote and Jackson Pollock.
- •LDV at The Maidstone in East Hampton has been operating for over 150 years and was most recently restored in 2024.
- •The Reform Club in Amagansett collaborated with Lulu and Georgia for a garden and communal area refresh unveiled on May 11.
- •Room at the Beach in Bridgehampton occupies a 1.5-acre property that includes a grove of redwood trees planted by Martha Stewart.
- •The Pridwin on Shelter Island is a nearly century-old property that underwent an extensive renovation four years ago.
The Hamptons, known for its coastal towns and seasonal appeal, features a collection of boutique hotels and inns that emphasize a low-key, residential atmosphere. Recent renovations and new openings have updated several iconic properties across areas including Sag Harbor, East Hampton, Amagansett, and Montauk, offering amenities ranging from private beach access to curated dining experiences.
Historic and Boutique Stays
Faraway in Sag Harbor, formerly known as Baron’s Cove, recently reopened with a nautical design featuring 67 guest rooms. In East Hampton, the 150-year-old LDV at The Maidstone was restored in 2024 and offers amenities like Frette linens and on-site Italian dining. Meanwhile, the iconic inn in East Hampton recently underwent a full renovation by designer David Netto, introducing a refreshed look and a "Beach Butler" service for guests.
Estate-Style and Coastal Retreats
The Reform Club in Amagansett, set on five acres, offers a mix of main house rooms and cottages, recently updated with new garden designs. Nearby, The Roundtree features a renovated 100-year-old barn and cottages adjacent to local farmland. For those seeking direct ocean access, Marram in Montauk focuses on surf culture with private lessons and an on-site Uruguayan-inspired café.
Resorts and Specialized Lodging
EHP Resort provides cottage-style accommodations with access to a marina, tennis courts, and pickleball. On Shelter Island, The Pridwin offers a range of activities including sailing and fishing, with new summer programming such as wellness residencies and cocktail events. Other options include Bridgehampton’s Room at the Beach, a former motor lodge with 10 rooms and a pool, and Topping Rose House, a 19th-century mansion featuring a restaurant by Jean Georges.
Timeline
- 1950sThe property now known as Faraway began attracting a notable artistic and literary crowd.
- May 11Lulu and Georgia unveiled a refresh of the gardens and communal areas at The Reform Club.
- JuneThe hotel formerly known as Baron’s Cove reopened under the new name Faraway.
Advertisement
This article was independently rewritten by ManyPress editorial AI from reporting originally published by Vogue.
