A review is underway after the Tasmanian Parole Board used a document generated with AI that cited non-existent case law in a parole decision.
Key facts
- •Susan Neill-Fraser was convicted of murdering Bob Chappell in 2009 and served 13 years in prison.
- •The Parole Board's conditions restricting Neill-Fraser's media access were declared invalid in court.
- •The board's document cited case law that does not exist.
- •Attorney General Guy Barnett has requested a formal explanation from the Parole Board.
- •The Prisoners Legal Service Tasmania is auditing two years of board decisions for signs of AI use.
The Tasmanian justice department has launched a review into the use of artificial intelligence in parole decisions following a procedural error. The investigation follows a court revelation that the state Parole Board relied on an AI-generated document containing fake case law to set conditions for convicted murderer Susan Neill-Fraser.
Parole Board Decision Challenged
Susan Neill-Fraser, who was convicted of murdering her partner Bob Chappell in 2009, was released on parole in 2022. The Parole Board subsequently imposed conditions prohibiting her from speaking to the media to claim her innocence. These conditions were recently deemed invalid in court after it was revealed the board relied on a document created with AI that cited non-existent legal precedents.
Official Response and Ongoing Audits
A justice department spokesperson confirmed the review aims to determine the extent to which AI has informed past decisions. While the Parole Board remains an independent body and has declined to comment on individual cases, state Attorney General Guy Barnett has requested an explanation, labeling the error unacceptable. Separately, the Prisoners Legal Service Tasmania is conducting its own two-year audit of board decisions to identify potential AI usage or further errors.
Timeline
- 2009Susan Neill-Fraser murdered her partner, Bob Chappell.
- 2022Neill-Fraser was released on parole after serving 13 years in prison.
- TuesdayThe Parole Board's use of AI was revealed in court.
- Friday eveningThe justice department confirmed a review into AI use is underway.
Advertisement
This article was independently rewritten by ManyPress editorial AI from reporting originally published by Guardian AI.
