An Iowa district judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by Donald Trump against the Des Moines Register and pollster J. Ann Selzer regarding 2024 election polling.
Key facts
- •Judge Scott J. Beattie ruled that the polling coverage is protected by the First Amendment.
- •The lawsuit claimed the Des Moines Register and J. Ann Selzer violated Iowa consumer fraud laws.
- •The judge stated the case failed to meet legal requirements for fraud or deception even if the poll were assumed to be fabricated.
- •Trump filed the lawsuit in December 2024, alleging the poll was intended to help Democrats.
- •The court warned that the lawsuit could discourage public debate and reporting.
Iowa District Court Judge Scott J. Beattie dismissed a lawsuit on Wednesday brought by Donald Trump against the Des Moines Register, its parent company, and pollster J. Ann Selzer. Trump’s legal team had accused the defendants of violating Iowa’s consumer fraud law by publishing inaccurate poll results ahead of the 2024 general election. The judge ruled that the polling and its coverage constitute constitutionally protected political speech rather than a commercial product.
Court Ruling and Legal Reasoning
Judge Beattie stated that the lawsuit attempted to stretch Iowa law beyond its current bounds, noting that the claims sought to turn speech protected by the First Amendment into a liability. He emphasized that allowing such a case to proceed could have a chilling effect on the reporting and debate of public affairs. Even when assuming for the purpose of the motion that the poll was intentionally skewed or fabricated, the judge concluded that the three counts of the lawsuit failed to meet the legal requirements for fraud or consumer deception. The defendants had previously characterized the lawsuit as a conspiracy theory and an affront to free speech protections.
Background of the Lawsuit
Filed in December 2024, the lawsuit alleged that the newspaper and its pollster published fraudulent data to damage Trump and assist Democrats. The legal action challenged the boundaries of press protections, which Trump has contested in various lawsuits against media organizations throughout his career. Some of those previous legal challenges have resulted in settlements.
Advertisement
This article was independently rewritten by ManyPress editorial AI from reporting originally published by The Hill, Guardian US Politics.
